0day streak
Well-established
Decision-Making
Decoy Effect
Decision-making principleDefinition
The phenomenon where adding a third, less attractive option (the decoy) makes one of the original two options seem more appealing.
Why it happens
We evaluate options relative to each other, not in absolute terms. A strategically placed decoy makes the target option look like a clear winner by comparison.
Real-life examples
- A medium popcorn priced almost as high as a large makes the large seem like the best deal.
- A subscription plan with fewer features at nearly the same price as the premium plan pushes you toward premium.
- A real estate agent showing you a slightly worse house at the same price to make the target house look better.
How to counter it
- Evaluate each option on its own merits, not relative to others.
- Mentally remove the middle option and check if your preference changes.
- Ask: "Would I choose this if the other options weren't there?"
- Be suspicious of pricing tiers that seem designed to push you toward one choice.
Quick tips
- Evaluate each option on its own merits, not relative to others.
- Remove the middle option mentally and see if your preference changes.
- Ask: 'Would I choose this if the other options weren't there?'
- Be suspicious when pricing structures seem designed to push you toward one choice.
Sources and further reading
- The attraction effect and the compromise effect in market choice
Wiley Online Library